Shedeur Sanders’ rookie season with the Browns is rated worse than Johnny Manziel’s Cleveland disaster in 2014

Shedeur Sanders hype hit Cleveland laborious after the 2025 NFL Draft, however 11 years in the past there was an excellent larger prospect, Johnny Manziel, who dramatically failed with the Browns and, after two seasons, needed to search for a possibility exterior the NFL.

Manziel wasn’t simply any prospect. The Browns chosen him with the twenty second total choose of the 2014 NFL Draft after the previous Texas A&M QB grew to become the primary freshman in historical past to win the Heisman in 2012.

That season, he piled up an SEC-record 4,600 yards of whole offense whereas main A&M to a 10-2 regular-season file. Manziel threw for 3,419 yards and 24 touchdowns whereas including 1,181 yards and 19 scores on the bottom.

The A&M star returned to high school in 2013 and threw for 4,114 yards and 37 touchdowns whereas speeding for 759 yards and 9 scores. His two-year totals had been exceptional: 9,989 whole yards of offense and 93 touchdowns. He was as soon as once more voted to the Heisman ceremony as a finalist, ending fifth behind Jameis Winston.

Manziel, higher than Sanders in debut season

Shedeur needed to wait till Week 11 to get a possibility in NFL motion, however after three video games, he’s already rated decrease than Manziel by ESPN’s QBR. Sanders has a QBR of seven.0, whereas Manziel posted a 7.8 after 5 video games in his rookie season.

ESPN’s QBR incorporates all of a quarterback’s contributions to profitable, together with how he impacts the sport on passes, rushes, turnovers, and penalties. It additionally accounts for a workforce’s degree of success or failure on each play.

Sanders and Manziel appear to be headed for the same destiny within the NFL, as their rookie stats are very shut. Their completion charges are almost equivalent: Sanders is at 50.8%, whereas Manziel had 51.4%. One other comparable stat is yards per go try: Shedeur has 6.6, and Johnny had 5.0.

One space the place Manziel is clearly higher than Sanders is avoiding sacks. Sanders has been sacked six occasions in three video games, whereas Manziel was sacked solely thrice in 5 outings. The previous Aggies star additionally scored a speeding TD throughout his rookie season-something Sanders has but to do.

Sanders has been closely criticized for taking too lengthy to discover a receiver. If we take away screens, Sanders turns into the QB with the bottom completion fee (42%) within the league, and he additionally has the best time to throw (3.6 seconds). It is a unhealthy mixture for those who take that lengthy, you have to discover a receiver.

All this places Manziel forward of Sanders as a rookie quarterback. We all know how Johnny’s profession ended, and hopefully Shedeur takes a unique path.

Manziel’s “disgrace” after failing within the NFL

Manziel just lately opened up about his failed NFL profession and mentioned he felt “disgrace and remorse” for not discovering success.

The previous school star admitted on the Particular Forces present: “I misplaced an enormous a part of my work ethic… I gave up on an actual alternative, a soccer profession, and walked away from it fairly fast.”

“After I had gotten all the pieces I might ever wished, I feel I used to be probably the most empty I ever felt inside. I feel I used to be making an attempt to suppress how I felt and get out of being Johnny Soccer,” he continued.

After I had gotten all the pieces I might ever wished, I feel I used to be probably the most empty I ever felt inside.

Johnny Manziel

Such is the stress on an NFL participant that, after his failure within the league, he “had purchased a gun that I knew I used to be going to make use of. I had deliberate to do all the pieces that I wished to do at that time in my life spend as a lot cash as I presumably may after which my plan was to take my very own life,” Manziel concluded.